Elegance and Heels: Good Manners, Excellent Shoes, Bad Intentions

· Heelsman

Red high-heeled pump beside a black leather lace-up dress shoe

Elegance is often described by people who would like you to buy something expensive and then speak very quietly about it. Apparently a woman in beige slingbacks is sophisticated, while a man in precisely the same shoes causes the entire committee to spill its tea. The shoes have done nothing. The committee has simply encountered a limitation in its education.

I find elegance more interesting when it contains a little tension. A silk blouse with sharp tailoring. Heavy jeans with fine suede ankle boots. A perfectly cut black suit interrupted by a thin, beautiful heel. Things are rarely more elegant merely because they are conventional.

What actually makes a heel look elegant?

Three elements do most of the work: proportion, finish and intention. Start with proportion. A shoe's heel, toe and upper form one shape, and that shape should relate to the clothes above it. Very wide trousers can reveal a narrow pump only when moving; tapered trousers show more of the ankle and entire heel. A low kitten heel can have as much visual refinement as a high stiletto.

Finish matters, although it is not synonymous with luxury. Smooth leather, well-maintained suede, carefully applied patent finish and neatly stitched edges can look deliberate at very different prices. A scruffy designer pump does not become elegant by presenting its invoice. See my guide to cleaning heels for the actual maintenance work behind all that effortless sophistication.

Intention is the difficult part. It means deciding what the outfit is trying to say. An outfit does not need to be subdued, but its components should have some reason to be together. If every item is shouting, nobody gets to deliver the punchline.

Black heels are not mandatory

Black is convenient. It sits comfortably beside navy, charcoal, cream and an enormous number of other colours. It is not an official uniform of taste. Oxblood suede with brown corduroy can be astonishingly good. Dark green boots can bring life to a grey coat. White pumps can look architectural rather than bridal if paired with precise tailoring.

Person in green corduroy trousers walking in suede high heels

The photograph in this article of green trousers and suede shoes illustrates why I like unexpected tonal combinations. Corduroy has texture; suede has a softer surface; together they feel studied rather than stiff. You could build a similar outfit with burgundy boots and tobacco-brown trousers, or with slate trousers and deep-blue heeled loafers.

Patterned shoes require a little planning. If the heel carries embroidery, crystals or a strong animal print, let the clothing provide breathing room. The decorative heels guide shows how elaborate shoes can dominate an outfit without completely overwhelming it.

Elegance is not limited to one gender

Heeled footwear has a history in elite menswear, which the Bata Shoe Museum's Standing TALL exhibition traces through Persian riding shoes and European court fashion. Gentlemen once wore elaborate heels as an outward sign of position. Modern ideas about respectable masculine shoes are much newer than many people imagine.

A contemporary man can use that history without dressing as Louis XIV. Picture straight dark trousers, a finely knitted turtleneck, a long overcoat and heeled Chelsea boots. Or a double-breasted suit with glossy low-heeled Oxfords. For the happily theatrical, a dark velvet jacket and narrow stilettos can make the point with considerably more volume.

In men's outfits with heels, I go into the individual silhouettes. Here I want to defend a simpler principle: an elegant heel does not become inelegant when its wearer has broad shoulders or facial hair. The eye should judge the outfit before the stereotype starts making speeches.

The paradox of business elegance

A workplace often demands clarity, safety and restraint. That does not mean absolute boredom. Well-fitted heeled loafers, ankle boots or Oxford heels can make a beautiful alternative to flat shoes, where the dress code and working conditions allow them.

Orange and cream high-heeled shoes displayed on shelving

I am fond of the idea of entering a meeting looking polished enough to be mistaken for the person who owns the building. I am less fond of meeting a slippery office staircase at speed. The practical concerns in work heels are real: standing time, floor surfaces, security of fit and whether you need spare shoes to commute.

The greater mistake is to confuse authority with heel height. Plenty of accomplished people wear flats. Plenty of fools wear expensive pumps. The relationship is charmingly unscientific.

Can a very high platform still look elegant?

Yes, though it may achieve a different kind of elegance. A glossy platform can look deliberately dramatic with a sharply cut jacket or a floor-length coat. The continuous visual line matters more than the number of centimetres. A structured platform with a clean upper can feel refined; a delicate slingback with badly placed embellishment can feel chaotic.

That said, a high platform is not automatically easy to walk in. The outsole stiffness, the difference between heel and forefoot height, and the contact surface still matter. My comparison of platforms and stilettos is a useful antidote to advertisements that promise effortless altitude.

The same applies to vintage and unusual heels. A curved French heel offers historical charm without requiring an entire eighteenth-century costume. It is sophistication with a slight tendency to arrive late to dinner.

Five situations, five moods

For a gallery visit, try straight trousers, a fine shirt and low heeled boots. You want to look as though you understand the exhibition, even if the conceptual installation is currently winning.

Assorted high heels in black, grey, red and nude displayed near an elegant sofa

For dinner, choose a single luxurious texture: suede pumps with an understated outfit, patent ankle boots with matte wool, or metallic heels against dark tailoring.

For a formal reception, a slender pump or elegant block heel can work, provided it fits the floor and the amount of standing. Add one accessory that repeats a detail from the shoe.

For an ordinary Saturday, heeled loafers with jeans and a coat can look deliberate without turning a coffee run into a charity gala.

For a night when you want trouble, wear the outfit that makes you smile when you look in the mirror. Elegance has survived centuries of changing fashion. It can cope with a little mischief.

A final lesson in expensive restraint

The point is not that everyone should buy costly clothes or worship a narrow set of rules. Elegance is attention to detail, proportion and occasion. Sometimes that demands taking one accessory off. Sometimes it demands putting a magnificent pair of red heels on.

As for me, I prefer the second option whenever practical. Restraint is important, certainly, but it should never be allowed to ruin a very good shoe.

Sources and further reading