Dream Heels: A Very Expensive Conversation with Myself

In my imagination there is a wardrobe containing one perfectly chosen pair of shoes for every occasion. They are immaculately arranged, every heel is intact, and I always remember exactly where the black suede boots live. This is how I know it is a fantasy.
Dream heels are the shoes you notice across a shop floor or in a photograph and then remember for days. Perhaps a sculptural boot that looks as if it could conduct an orchestra. Perhaps a red pump with the kind of neckline that makes a sensible trouser seem suddenly underdressed. Perhaps the ideal pair is a modest, beautifully finished Mary Jane and not an elaborate monument to poor budgeting.
Before you buy the fantasy, I suggest interviewing it. Beautiful shoes are allowed to be troublesome. They are not entitled to lie.

What does your ideal pair actually look like?
Forget the brand for a moment. Describe the shape. Is the toe pointed, almond or square? A low Cuban heel or a tall stiletto? A closed boot that turns jeans into an outfit, or an open sandal that makes all your socks redundant?
Next, consider the effect you want. If you like a severe tailored silhouette, black patent pumps or heeled Oxfords may work. If your personal aesthetic is closer to a glam-rock villain with a generous entertainment budget, explore platform heels and the magnificent excesses of decorative heels.
The photograph usually tells only half the story. Ask for a rear view, the outsole and the heel base. Product listings that show nothing but dramatic side angles may have something to hide, and it is not necessarily a desirable mystery.
The wish list is a magnificent lie detector
Keep a short list of shoes you want and leave it alone for a few weeks. If one pair survives the novelty of a new collection, the attraction may be real. If your obsession fades by Friday, congratulations: you have saved money and avoided a box that would eventually become an architectural feature beneath your bed.

Record the brand, model, material, heel height, platform height, actual foot measurements and return policy. Compare shapes rather than shopping by a single size label. My large sizes guide and width guide help distinguish the thrill of finding your size from the disappointment of finding a shoe with the wrong last.
The dream pair is the pair you want to wear, not simply the pair you want to own. There is an important difference. Collecting is a perfectly reasonable hobby, but let us be honest about whether we are buying footwear or commissioning a miniature sculpture.
Can expensive heels justify their price?
Sometimes. Better leather, careful pattern cutting, a sound heel attachment and repairable construction can matter. But a famous logo is not evidence that the toe box fits. Handwork can be excellent; it can also be invoked in advertising with impressive vagueness. Ask precisely which parts are made or finished by hand.

My guide to luxury heels examines retailers and workmanship, while the world's most expensive heels explains why astronomical valuations are not a reliable measure of wearability.
I have seen shoes so extravagantly decorated that they appear to be waiting for a security guard rather than a foot. No insult intended. Some are splendid objects. I merely reserve the right to prefer a pair I can actually walk to dinner in.
Fantasy materials meet inconvenient weather
Imagine those dream shoes in your ordinary life. Will polished leather tolerate regular use? Are the delicate suede heels going to spend their existence dodging rain? Does the design demand spotless indoor floors when your evenings begin with twenty minutes of municipal pavement?

For a very occasional party shoe, delicate materials can be a sensible compromise. For a daily boot, weather resistance, grip and ease of care deserve more attention. There is no universal winner between leather, synthetics and textiles. Each material comes with its own maintenance, durability and ethical questions.
Even the most charming patent finish can show scuffs. Velvet dislikes moisture. Clear plastic straps can rub. A large platform may protect the sole from some pavement dirt but can also change how your foot moves. Every glamour has paperwork.
Try the shoe in the conditions you can control
At home, use a clean floor, secure the straps and walk at an ordinary pace. Look for heel lift, sliding toes, pressure on the outer edge and any unstable movement. Check both feet. If you plan to dance, gently turn and stop as well as walking straight. A stationary mirror pose will not tell you how the shoe behaves while moving.

The American Academy of Dermatology recommends properly fitting shoes to help reduce friction and blisters. Do not interpret severe rubbing as a romantic prelude to the shoe breaking in. A romantic prelude should be considerably more pleasant.
If you are buying online, the FTC advises checking seller reputation, delivery terms and return policies. Know whether you can return a tried-on pair and who pays postage before you click the button. Admiration is allowed. Blind financial commitment is not required.
Do dream shoes ever need to be worn?
Here comes the sentimental part, for which I apologise only slightly. The pair you wear to an important dinner or an ordinary Tuesday develops a life your display shelf cannot provide. It takes on the shape of your routine, your preferred clothes and the places you actually go. Its slight creases become evidence that someone chose pleasure over sterile perfection.
That does not mean deliberately wrecking an expensive pair. Store them properly. Repair heel tips when needed. Rotate pairs. I have an entire guide to organising a heel collection because footwear has an alarming talent for multiplying.

And what if you literally dream about high heels?
Some readers arrive here after dreaming about shoes while asleep. I cannot tell you that a red stiletto in a dream predicts success, romance or a surprise inheritance. Those are imaginative interpretations, not reliable facts about your future. Dreams can borrow objects from memories, emotions and recent experiences; a universal shoe dictionary has not been scientifically established.
You are welcome to turn the image into fiction, poetry or an extravagant new outfit. Just do not buy a £900 pair because a stranger on the internet announced that your subconscious requires one. Your bank account deserves a vote.
My own dream? A perfectly proportioned heel, exquisite material, a fit that feels deliberate and a price that does not require selling the furniture. I understand that last element may be the least realistic.